Themes

Peer review card game

What is this about?

Peer review card exchange game was developed by researchers from the University of Split School of Medicine as a hands-on training session for a summer school on peer review (1). It is an educational tool designed to inform young researchers about integrity in peer review. The game is free to use, and available here.

Why is this important?

Peer review is an important part of scientific process, because it identifies both quality and possible flaws in submitted research, and offers room for improvement. However, the peer review process is not perfect, and is susceptible to a number of conflicts, dilemmas and insecurities (2,3).

For whom is this important?

Students, PhD Students, Supervisors, Postdocs, Reviewers

What are the best practices?

The use of card exchange games is an approach used in teaching the philosophy of science. It was developed by Bergquist and Phillips in 1975 and later popularized by Cobern (4). The idea of card games is to foster dialogue between participants about statements written on cards, and such games have been effective in improving students’ knowledge.

In the peer review card exchange game, six different domains of peer review are explored by different statements written on cards. Participants can agree or disagree with the statements, but they are asked to discuss them and reach a consensus as a group. The explored domains are: responsiveness, competence, impartiality, confidentiality, constructive criticism and responsibility to science. Participants have to find which cards they all agree on. After that, they participate in a moderated discussion.

References

1. Peer review card exchange game, available at: http://europeanscienceediting.eu/articles/a-peer-review-card-exchange-game/

2. Hames I. Peer review at the beginning of the 21st century. Science Editing. 2014;1(1):4-8.

3. Csiszar A. Peer review: Troubled from the start. Nature. 2016;532(7599):306-8. Epub 2016/04/26.

4. Cobern WW. Introducing teachers to the philosophy of science: The card exchange. Journal of Science Teacher Education. 1991;2(2):45-6.

Ružica Tokalić contributed to this theme.

Latest contribution was May 29, 2019